TD Cowen’s Jason Gabelman argues the oil market is reacting too fast to a possible easing in Middle East tensions, with the Strait of Hormuz still uncertain and medium-term oil prices likely reset higher than pre-conflict assumptions.
Watch on YouTube ›Get the market thesis, key claims, assets, contradictions, and follow-up questions from any financial video — then unlock a version personalized to your portfolio, watchlist, and favorite speakers.
In this CNBC segment, the host frames the oil move as a knee-jerk reaction after oil prices fell 11% and energy infrastructure restoration estimates were cited at $34B-$58B. Jason Gabelman of TD Cowen says the market is “shooting first and asking questions later,” emphasizing that it remains unclear whether shipping through the Strait of Hormuz is materially improving. He notes Iran’s requirement that ships be approved by the IRGC to pass through the Iranian route, and says it is too early to know whether the latest news will increase transits over the weekend. On scenarios, Gabelman says the near-term outcome is highly uncertain, but over the medium term all parties have an interest in reopening the Strait because the global economy cannot absorb an extended closure. …
Near term, the setup is headline-driven and fragile: if shipping normalizes less than expected, the oil and energy-stock pullback can unwind quickly. If weekend news shows more transit or a credible ceasefire, equities may stay under pressure even as crude stabilizes.
Over the next few weeks to months, the base case is a gradual reopening of the Strait and a market that keeps a higher oil-price assumption than before the conflict. Energy names should trade on whether the supply backdrop and geopolitical premium persist, with refiners and gas-linked businesses likely to remain relatively favored.
Structurally, the transcript points to a tighter oil regime than the pre-conflict oversupply narrative implied. If shale plateaus and non-OPEC growth slows, geopolitical shocks may keep resetting the floor for energy prices and the valuation of integrated oils, refiners, and gas infrastructure.
The market is reacting too aggressively to the latest oil news.
He says the market is 'shooting first and asking questions later' in response to the pullback.
It is still unclear whether the Strait of Hormuz is becoming materially more open to shipping.
He cites Iran's approval requirement and says it is unclear whether today's news will increase transits.
The Strait is likely to reopen over the medium term because the global economy cannot tolerate a prolonged closure.
He says all parties have an interest in reopening the Strait and the economy cannot absorb an extended shutdown.
What did you make of the 11% pullback? Was this premature?
Gabelman says the market seems to be reacting too quickly and that it is still unclear whether the Strait of Hormuz is actually becoming more open to shipping.
What is the most likely scenario for opening the Strait and who are the winners?
He says the near term is hard to call, but over the medium term the Strait should reopen. That would likely help energy infrastructure-linked names and leave gas, diesel, integrated oils, and refiners with support.
What oil price is being incorporated into stock valuations now?
He says the market likely moved from pricing around $60 WTI to closer to $70 WTI, which he thinks is the correct reset.
Unlock the full claims, asset map, scores, related transcripts, follow-up questions, and AI chat — shaped around your portfolio, watchlist, favorite speakers, and risks.
