Will Saletan of The Bulwark argues that under Trump, US foreign policy has become a profit-driven extortion racket — extracting minerals from Ukraine, oil from Venezuela, and now targeting Iran's Kharg Island, Strait of Hormuz tolls, and coerced food purchases. He presents this as a moral crisis: America has abandoned being "the good guys" and is now acting like "pirates," with Congress and the Secretary of War complicit.
Watch on YouTube ›Get the market thesis, key claims, assets, contradictions, and follow-up questions from any financial video — then unlock a version personalized to your portfolio, watchlist, and favorite speakers.
Will Saletan opens by framing a stark moral question: is the United States becoming "the world's most powerful criminal" under Donald Trump? He builds his case as a prosecutor would, layering evidence chronologically and thematically. **The Ukraine precedent.** Saletan begins with the mildest form of the alleged profiteering: Trump forcing Ukraine to share mineral rights in exchange for military aid that Biden had given freely. He plays a Trump clip where the president boasts, "I got rare earth back... …
Short-term: the transcript does not offer a market view, but the underlying events it documents — explicit US threats to seize Iranian oil infrastructure and tax Strait of Hormuz transit — represent genuine near-term tail risk for crude oil supply chains and maritime insurance pricing in the Persian Gulf.
Medium-term: if the Strait of Hormuz toll or Kharg Island seizure materializes even partially, the oil market would need to reprice both physical supply risk and the precedent of the US acting as a rent-seeking gatekeeper rather than a neutral security provider — this changes the risk-free assumption around Gulf shipping.
Long-term: the structural risk Saletan identifies — whether accurately framed or not — is that US military power shifts from underpinning the global commons to extracting rents from it. If that perception takes hold, it erodes the foundation of dollar hegemony, alliance reliability, and the post-WWII trade order over a multi-year horizon.
Trump wants to seize Kharg Island and take control of Iran's oil, similar to what he did in Venezuela.
Speaker cites Trump's Truth Social post and quotes from an interview where Trump said 'You can make a fortune.'
Trump forced Ukraine to give the US a share of their minerals in exchange for military aid, making a profit on what the US gave.
Speaker cites Trump's own statement about getting rare earth back and getting more value than weapons given.
Trump's administration made a profit 40 times the cost of the Venezuela invasion by taking oil.
Speaker quotes Trump bragging about taking tremendous amounts of oil and making 40x returns.
What did Trump say about forcing Iran to buy food from American farmers?
Trump stated that as part of negotiations, unfrozen Iranian money will be used to buy food exclusively from US farmers - corn, soybeans and other things Iran needs. He said American farmers are 'very happy' about this new exclusive market.
What did Trump say about the Saudis and using their airports?
Trump said the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia is happy the US is using their airports, adding 'Not that they could stop us if we didn't want them to' - bragging that America's allies cannot stop the US from doing what it wants.
What did Trump learn about the limits on his power?
Trump responded 'There are no limits' and said 'We defeated them totally militarily. I think that there are no limits. We have the most powerful military in the world by far.'
Unlock the full claims, asset map, scores, related transcripts, follow-up questions, and AI chat — shaped around your portfolio, watchlist, favorite speakers, and risks.